“Clearly Wrong”: Serie A Chief Apologizes for Kalulu Red Card vs. Inter

• 1 min read
Juventus defender Pierre Kalulu shown a second yellow card against Inter as VAR protocol prevents review

Juventus clash with Inter exploded after Pierre Kalulu was dismissed for a second yellow, following a fall from Alessandro Bastoni. Replays fueled outrage because the incident looked like a minimal-contact (or no-contact) trigger for a match-changing decision.

The most important detail: because the punishment came from a second caution, VAR couldn’t step in under the current protocol—even if video evidence suggests the decision was incorrect. The controversy grew when Serie A’s refereeing chief Gianluca Rocchi publicly apologized, calling the call “clearly wrong.”

THE VERDICT
Decision: Second Yellow → Red Card
Rating: 🟥 Catastrophic (Protocol Trap)
Analysis: This is the nightmare scenario: a send-off created by a caution incident that VAR is not allowed to fix. If video can clearly prove a decisive error (including exaggerated falls), the protocol must allow a review—otherwise VAR becomes a “highlights machine” instead of a fairness tool.

Narek Smbatyan
Written by

Narek Smbatyan

Narek Smbatyan is the creator and lead analyst of The VAR Verdict. Driven by a passion for the technicalities of the sport, [Your Name] provides a deep dive into the Laws of the Game to make sense of football’s most debated moments. By meticulously reviewing VAR protocols and officiating standards, The VAR Verdict serves as a bridge between the complex rulebook and the fans who live for the game.

View author page

Tags