In the 86th minute of a 1-1 deadlock, Girona’s Claudio Echeverri contested a loose ball with Jules Koundé. Replays (and this image) show Echeverri’s studs landing directly on Koundé’s ankle. Referee César Soto Grado allowed play to continue, and moments later, Fran Beltrán struck the winning goal to make it 2-1.
Robbed at Montilivi? The “Clear and Obvious” Stamp That Cost Barcelona the League Lead
The VAR Failure
Despite the goal-scoring phase starting with this potential foul, VAR David Gálvez did not advise a pitchside review. This is particularly controversial because the Technical Committee of Referees (CTA) reportedly admitted just hours later that VAR should have intervened.
The "VAR Verdict"
Decision: Goal Stood.
Our Rating
❌ Incorrect Decision.
Reasoning
Under current IFAB guidelines, a “stamp” in the build-up to a goal is a factual foul that must be reviewed. The inconsistency is glaring: Soto Grado overturned a similar goal for Barcelona last season for a much lighter contact.
Key Takeaways
Every verdict depends on context, available angles and the Laws of the Game. We clearly separate confirmed facts from interpretation.
Written by
Narek Smbatyan
Narek Smbatyan is the creator and lead analyst of The VAR Verdict. Driven by a passion for the technicalities of the sport, Narek provides a deep dive into the Laws of the Game to make sense of football’s most debated moments. By meticulously reviewing VAR protocols and officiating standards, The VAR Verdict serves as a bridge between the complex rulebook and the fans who live for the game.
View author page
0 Comments
Join the conversation with respect. Comments are moderated and must follow our community rules.
Want to join the discussion?
Please log in or create an account to comment and reply. This keeps the conversation cleaner and safer.